
This rant may seem a little behind the 8 ball as I posted it on my FB page the week of the movies release, forsaking poor old je nai sai quoi. So here it is:
The first few bars of music played and grown ups gasped some clapping with excitement and then the hush of a crowd waiting to be told a story. Alicia Keyes' fusing of Blondie's Rapture and the cult theme music had the audience in well rapture, with the first half hour bringing us to be speed on the characters we cherish.
Then the ladies hit Abu Dhabi and my trip to Wonderland turned into a nightmare. The cultural cringe was thick and heavy and kicked off with the girls arrival. On meeting their butlers Charlotte is called by her maiden name York instead of her Jewish married name Goldenblatt. A small reference is made to Charlotte's switch with her response of "Well this IS the middle east". I'm not quite sure what 'Charlotte's' implication is here? That if Muslim people found out that she is Jewish she would somehow be treated unfairly? I shook the thought out of my head and decided to give the writers the benefit of the doubt. Charlotte is known for her paranoid behaviour when she is confronted with the unfamiliar, much like her avoidance of drinking any water that wasn't bottled when holidaying in Mexico in the first SATC film but the 'jokes' and observations that followed were a little harder to forgive.
Over lunch at the women's hotel they begin to pan the poor woman sitting at the adjacent table. Her crime? She is wearing a niqab and has ordered a bowl of french fries. Now don't get me wrong I too was curious as to how the woman would manage to eat her meal and felt a little stupid when all she did was pop a fry in under her veil. But the attitude of the formerly fab four wasn't so humble they not only poked fun at women who wear niqab's they also vehemently vented their opinion on wearing veils altogether. This opinion isn't my problem here it's the blatant disgust of a tradition in a country where YOU are a guest. How can my Contiki host have more humility than this entire production. Her catch cry for every country we were lucky enough to be visiting was "It's not wrong, it's just different'. A concept lost on everyone involved in this film. The portrayal of Abu Dhabi is one of an oppressive, misogynist regime with Samantha leading the way in terms of disrespect.
I read online that Cynthia Nixon told the Hollywood Reporter, "Samantha is disrespectful, but Samantha is disrespectful in New York and she is disrespectful in the Middle East and she just really doesn't care". The movie's director and writer Michael Patrick King, adds, "The reality is Samantha Jones is outrageous wherever she goes, whether it be Starbucks... Or Abu Dhabi. She is an unapologetic individual". That is all good and well but the jokes aren't set up so we laugh at Samantha's outrageousness it's set up to laugh at what they see as the 'outrageousness' of a culture they don't understand or care too.
They are ALL seen laughing at Muslim women bathing in 'bikini burqas' a point in the film where I wanted to scream, "YOU ARE IN THEIR COUNTRY DICKHEADS". Well actually I lie the film does use Miranda as cultural conduit with careless and over simplified explanations of what's going on around them. Not that any of what Miranda says matters as they traipse around town like an obnoxious dinner guest.
As the film went on I sunk lower and lower into my seat with the climax of cultural cringe culminating in a scene where Samantha's purse falls to the ground in the middle of the Souk Market and it's contents of condoms spew across the cobblestones. Samantha dressed in hot pants and killer cleavage singlet bends down to pick them up to a horrified crowd of onlookers. 'Samantha's' reaction is to scream a mighty FUCK YOU to the Muslim crowd, give the one fingered salute and simulate sex announcing "Yes I have sex". The crowd becomes agitated and they ladies are 'saved' by a group of Muslim women dressed in niqabs. They follow them into a back room where the unveil themselves and shock and gasp they are wearing the next designer spring collection underneath their robes! And hahaha the men will be talking about this for weeks hehehe. Now I'm not debating the fact that these women are better dressed than I will ever be,or that the men may be talking about the incident for months. It's the cliche moment of 'Oh actually we are so alike'. And to make matters worse how do they escape the crowd of angry men outside, YES they dress up in niqabs and so begins the slapstick escape routine.
This type of humour is low brow and from creators of such an iconic series the writing is just plain lazy. Yes in between the scenes where my hand actually covered my eyes in embarrassment was the funny that we know and love but where I once lost myself in the fun, I now felt a little uncomfortable. It was like laughing at your drunken uncle at Christmas. 90% of his jokes are completely inappropriate but every now and then he hands out a gem and you feel you have to cover the corners of your creeping mouth in fear of encouraging him.
My question to everyone involved in the creation of this film is simply why? Why choose Abu Dhabi? Why if you have next to nothing nice to say about a culture do you choose to set your film within it? Why when America and New York especially has such a controversial history with extremist muslims do you decide to poke the bear and make fun of their city, their women and their way of life? Perhaps you should realise regardless of your 'intentions' you have demeaned not only another culture but women, you never investigate a Muslim woman's motivation in wearing a niqab. Whether you agree with her choice or not, I would have thought people who grew up in the land of the free would be a little more open to tolerance. You so clearly assume we are stupid, you assume the glitz and glam will blind us to the lack of respect to our sisters of the Middle East. Wasn't that the point of SATC2? That no matter what happens you have your female 'soulmates' supporting you? Perhaps you could have cut down on the endless scenes of blatant product placement and decadence of wonderland and create an actual voice for the women you obviously feel are oppressed. Let them tell their story. Shine a light on tolerance and understanding instead of widening the gap of difference and for fuck's sake sing it loud Aretha show some R E S P E C T.
What I'm asking of you my fellow femmes is to demand a higher standard. Don't be blinded by Dolce and the newly appointed Chief Creative Officer Sarah Jessica Parker's Halston Heritage. Ask them to perhaps explore what began as an important theme in the movie. Judgement. Because we would all be more powerful as women if we conquered that, our Achilles Heel.
My love for Carrie has definitely now lost that certain je nai sais quoi...